Ariel Lanyi, Pianist
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
Ariel Lanyi, Pianist
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
June 14, 2014 10:26 pm No Comments Ariel Lanyi

I find Chopin’s Scherzo No. 3 Op. 39 to be unique among the four that he wrote. There is a “motif” that repeats throughout the scherzo, which I call the orchestral motif.

Not only are the two phrases divided, the two parts of the phrase are “played by different instruments.” If this were an orchestral piece, the beginnings of the phrases would be played by a certain group of instruments, and the extensions would be played by a different group. This is the “orchestral effect,” and it shows up often in the scherzo, especially in parts that are not so “pianistic.” This is what makes this scherzo so unique. The other three scherzos, especially the first, are very pianistic, and they display a great amount of virtuosity, as does the third. But the third, with all its virtuosity (Arthur Rubinstein said that it took more energy out of him than any other piece, and he played Brahms’ Second Concerto and Liszt’s First), is much more orchestral and in my opinion, and it is the deepest of the four. In every section of this piece, this motif is repeated.

After the introduction, Chopin exposes the first (and main) theme of the piece, beginning from the Risoluto.

This is one of the clearest examples of the orchestration of this piece (although Chopin was not the greatest orchestrator…) The Risoluto begins with thetutti, until the long G# tenuto. After that, it is a clear solo (perhaps a bassoon or another wind instrument). After the short solo, there is another explosive tutti. All of these “split personalities” that appear in the scherzo are very difficult to bring out, and I find it lacking in most of the performances (Argerich, Pogorelich, Pollini, Ashkenazy, and even Horowitz). What I’m looking for in a performance of this scherzo is a distinct difference between the Risoluto and the three-bar solo that comes after it. After the role-playing of the beginning, Chopin develops the first theme, starting at the last bar of the first line.

Although there is no real orchestral role-playing here, I’m still inclined to think that this is less pianistic than Chopin’s other scherzos. Because of the orchestration, I find this piece very colorful, and this is what I’m looking for in a performance. As it happens, most performances do not bring out the color and the excitement of this piece. I find most performances very “scientific.” Moreover, many performers forget the meaning of the word “scherzo” when they play this piece. Scherzo, after all, is a joke, something humorous.

This scherzo is also the most dramatic of the four. The other scherzos, at the beginning, go straight to the theme. This scherzo doesn’t. There is a sense of insecurity, of lack of confidence before the scherzo really “begins” and the festive atmosphere to the piece takes over.

After the rhythmic first theme, Chopin introduces a lyrical section. I find this section the most orchestral of all.

Here the distinction is even clearer than before. The phrases are divided into groups or four bars. For example, the first four bars are played by strings, and they hold their last note while a harp plays a fast descending passage (This section reminds me of Rachmaninov).

Chopin finishes the melody in this pattern, then expands it in a late romantic (Wagner/Brahms/Rachmaninov) style.

Notice that the harp line always remains, while the other lines constantly change in this section. Chopin literally repeats the section twice, but with a change in texture and orchestration. This is where the orchestral motif comes in. Additionally, the soaring melody is followed by a disconnected, mysterious, and even unmelodic connecting line.

Finally, comes the part that I see as purely pianistic.

After this part, Chopin repeats the lyrical section and prepares the rhythmic first section in a most beautiful way that reminds me of a professionally filmed movie, with mastered fadeouts and transitions. Chopin combines the lyrical middle section with the rhythmic, assertive first section in an amazingly smooth way, but not in a kitschy way or in bad taste. Everything is in the right proportion, at the right time. As the recently heard subject of the lyrical theme dissolves, the first theme approaches. This is one of the most difficult places in the scherzo to perform, and many people fail to bring out the first theme while fading out the lyrical theme. Suddenly the lyrical theme appears, but not in D flat major but in E major.

This is another moment of insecurity, like in the beginning. And shortly after the presentation of the lyrical subject in E major, Chopin “restarts” the process of bringing back the first theme. This is also part of the “joke,” of the humor that is present in this piece.

Once again, Chopin perfectly combines the lyrical subject and the energetic, virtuosic motif. The right hand is lyrical while the left hand is energetic and virtuosic, a true split personality.

Chopin builds a massive crescendo and lightly hints at the first theme (using octaves), but without repeating it. Instead, he finishes with a highly virtuosic and pianistic coda.

The “orchestral effect” doesn’t appear any more in the form in which it appeared before. From here on, Chopin returns to his standard pianistic style of writing. This is why I find this scherzo so unique, especially in its middle lyrical section, when the “orchestral effect” appears.

Performances

There are many performances of this scherzo that I don’t like, including those of Ashkenazy, Argerich, Pollini, and Horowitz. My favorite performance is by the great Chopin interpreter Arthur Rubinstein. Not only does the orchestral effect come out so well, but this is the most “romantic” one of the performances I have heard. The romantic phrasing and sound make it for me the ideal performance of this scherzo.

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

You must be logged in to post a comment.

©2021 All Rights Reserved.
website by wp-factory
Scroll to top