Ariel Lanyi, Pianist
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
Ariel Lanyi, Pianist
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Videos
  • Dates
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Contact
June 16, 2014 7:54 pm No Comments Ariel Lanyi

The book “Alfred Brendel about Music” is a collection of thirty-seven essays by Brendel, and three interviews with him.

Brendel, widely considered a Schubertist, also writes a lot about Liszt. Some consider it strange that an intellectual like Brendel spends so much time on Liszt. He starts by saying “If one should happen to play a Beethoven sonata in the same programme, they are apt to shut their ears, as it were, and project onto the performance all the prejudices they have against Liszt: his alleged bombast, superficiality, cheap sentimentality, formlessness, his striving after effect for effect’s sake.” I totally agree with what Brendel says in this sentence. For one should remember that Liszt, who was the “man of the big occasions,” was still an intellectual pianist. He was the one to combine bombast with thoughtfulness. So what Brendel says is that the “bombastic pianists” who play Liszt (Cziffra, Richter, Kissin, Ginzburg, Berman, Horowitz, Jando and many others) completely changed the conception of the composer. It can be said that they “brainwashed” the audience with their ideas. I’m not saying that I don’t like the way these people play Liszt (I think that they play Liszt better than Brendel in certain cases), but there is a very intellectual take to Liszt, too. Liszt, after all performed music of the Classical period (as well as the Romantic period and his own compositions).

In my opinion, Brendel does not address enough the real virtuosic aspect of Liszt. The way he puts it, Liszt can be taken as intellectually as Schubert and Schumann. He also makes a point with which I highly disagree, about paying a great deal of attention to the pedal marks in Liszt. This means playing lines after lines from the Mephisto Waltz no.1 on one pedal, while not using any pedal for lines upon lines where the pedal is needed. In the Fantasy and Fugue on the Theme B-A-C-H Liszt does not indicate any pedal for over five lines. I don’t think any pianist in his right mind (not even Brendel) would keep his foot off the pedal in these lines.

“It is a peculiarity of Liszt’s music that it faithfully and fatally mirrors the character of its interpreter. When the works give the impression of being hollow, superficial and pretentious, the fault lies usually with the performer, occasionally with the (prejudiced) listener, and only rarely with Liszt himself” Brendel writes. I totally agree with this. The composer wrote all of his works for himself to perform. It is a completely different type of intellectuality in music, the intellectuality of the overall effect, projecting a certain image that goes along with the music (Années de Pélerinage suites, Villa d’Este, Venezia e Napoli). The same goes for Scriabin, Rachmaninoff, Prokofiev and even Brahms. By contrast, about Rachmaninoff, Brendel says the following: “Composers as dissimilar as Liszt and Rachmaninov are sometimes mentioned in the same breath, as if genius and the art of elevated conversations were only one step apart. When the difference between a great man and a grand seigneur is so lightly ignored, one must regard any enthusiasm for Liszt with caution.” I agree that there is a very big difference between Liszt and Rachmaninov, but I also think that the composers are not so dissimilar (again, not that they are similar). Rachmaninov’s music is basically Liszt extended. While Liszt makes an effect of an extra-musical idea (literature, nature…), Rachmaninov makes a grand effect (grand seigneur) with his music, fitted to the concert hall. Again, original Rachmaninov is not what pianists today make out of him (Richter, Lugansky, Kissin, Gilels, Ashkenazy, Watts, Entremont, Bronfman, Horowitz, Gavrilov, Volodos, Jando and many others). Rachmaninov today is one of the “bangiest” composers for the piano, since pianists take advantage of the big chords, the very pianistic qualities in the music… Don’t get me wrong, all these pianists play Rachmaninoff well, it is just not authentic Rachmaninov. Rachmaninov himself never banged on the piano. So in this way, Liszt and Rachmaninov are similar (as are Brahms, Busoni, Prokofiev, Bartok and Scriabin).
After all, Brendel is still the most thoughtful of pianists. So his take on Liszt is extreme. Extremely intellectual. Liszt is double-sided: both virtuosic and intellectual. If Ginzburg had written this essay, he would not have paid much attention to the intellectuality and the complexity of Liszt. He would have paid more attention to the effects themselves, and to the “overall” effect. What makes good Liszt is a combination of the two sides.

Here is Brendel playing Liszt’s Petrarch Sonnet No 104:

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

You must be logged in to post a comment.

©2021 All Rights Reserved.
website by wp-factory
Scroll to top